1 - Group classes
Pros: Not too expensive.
Cons: Not enough personal attention, curriculum not adapted to your real needs.
If you are an advanced student looking for a French conversation class, group classes can be a great option. If you are "good" with languages, and know how grammar works, you can also do well in a group. Otherwise, in my experience, group classes are a waste of time and money. Why? they won't adapt to your needs, whether you are getting your needs fulfilled or not.
From a teacher's/school point of view, group classes are a "juicy" business. You can easily make over $100/hr... Always keep that in mind when joining a class...
Here are some tips on what to look out for:
- The number of students. The more students, the less individual attention. Make sure you always know the maximum number of students allowed before joining a class. 4 is optimal. 6 is OK. 10 is way too many.
- Holidays. You usually pay a group class for X number of weeks. If your class day falls on a holiday, you won't have class, but you'll still have paid for it. This is particularly important if you join a group class in France, where there are so many holidays!!
- Teachers. Some unscrupulous schools will hire anyone... Do check the accent of your teacher before signing up for a class.
- The so-called placement test. Who interprets your level? Somehow, the results of the test often end up placing you in the class the director needs to fill...
- Group level. If you end up in a group with various levels, it’s going to be quite impossible to have a coherent group class. If you are between levels, pick the easiest one: it's beneficial to review something you already learned, but on the other hand, it's dangerous to skip levels and create gaps in your instruction.
If you cannot afford private instruction, then look into joining a group class, but consider taking a couple of private lessons here and there to make sure you do understand everything the class has covered, and address your own weaknesses.
2 - Private tutors, one on one classes, phone classes
Pros: curriculum totally adapted to your needs and learning abilities
Cons: price, danger of bad tutors
As you know, I give private French lessons, so I can tell you from experience. There are a lot of people out there that claim they can give French lessons, but cannot. You really have to check references and see for yourself before you commit to a large number of classes.
A tutor needs to be organized, punctual, reliable, have a good French accent, know grammar, know how to explain it, and be good at making people talk. Unfortunately, a lot of tutors out there are not. And degrees in French really cannot guarantee that this person will have the necessary personal skills...
Be particularly careful about young French people offering "conversation lessons". Often, they have no teaching experience whatsoever: they might be able to engage you in conversations, and point out your mistakes, but they won't be able to explain why it is a mistake... And that is primordial if you want to progress. At least, if you decide to go with this kind of tutors, make sure the price they charge is commensurate with their teaching abilities.
A good tutor should be able to tailor a program specially adapted to your strengths and weaknesses, and help you make the most of your time with him/her. You’re good with grammar? Then you can study most of it by yourself, and concentrate on practice and pronunciation during the lessons. You are too shy to speak? Your tutor has to reinforce natural everyday chats. Giving you a newspaper article to comment on is not going to help much in real life...
If you cannot find a good tutor in your area, don't overlook French phone lessons. I know it sounds intimidating, but phone lessons are very convenient, and my students who might have been reluctant at the beginning now love them.
3- Self-teaching methods
Pros: Cost. Convenience. Fun to use.
Cons: You will not learn French. No feedback. No grammar. No real person.
Who has not seen a box of Rosetta Stone for sale in a mall? While self-instruction methods can be a great complement to a formal instruction, I strongly believe none of them can teach you French by itself.
Why? No feedback. How will you know you pronounce the words correctly? The voice graph? Talk of a scam! They pick up your voice modulation, not your pronunciation... Worse, these methods often lack any solid grammatical structure, and you cannot master French without it. Other languages? Maybe. But not French. And everything is being "fed" to you: you'll never come up with a subject of conversation: that is not how real life works!
So, again, let me reinforce my message: they make great complements of lessons: you’ll learn new vocabulary, they will reinforce things you’ve learned, they are fun to use. But they are not efficient on their own.
Of course, whatever you get, audio is a must.
4 – French Immersion programs
Pros: You are surrounded by the language and its culture. Many opportunities to speak.
Cons: Price. Big danger of "fake" immersion.
The big danger of so-called immersion programs is that you might not be in real immersion. You’ll be getting group lessons, and then, you’ll be alone. Or with other foreigners (I made great progress in Spanish as I was studying in Oxford, England. All my fellow students were Spanish... Can't say I learned a lot of English though). A host family might not take the time to talk to you, or you can be stuck with toddlers and working parents...
To get the benefits of immersion, you need to make sure you get the opportunity to speak French. A lot of it. And it’s not because you are in the country that it is going to happen.
Of course, many of you have fond memories of your trip to France in a school: it’s fun, you do learn a lot, discover the culture, etc... Some schools are great, offer great curriculums and activities to entertain their students. Some host families do care and teach a lot to their guest. But I also know many students who had bad experiences, didn't get to practice French much, were mostly by themselves and ended up spending a lot of money without improving their French all that much.
Thankfully, there are some great immersion programs out there: check out immersion at a teacher’s house: this is the best of the best, because you are guaranteed to speak a lot of French, and have someone who can explain your mistakes and correct them. I highly recommend this option, it's the best and fastest way to learn French. Be careful though: there are some scams out there, so always check references, ask for a signed agreement stating clearly the conditions of your stay, pay a deposit but most of the money when you get there and you actually see your quarters and meet the teacher.
If you decide to go to a school, check the age of their students. Being surrounded by teenagers might get a little dull for a grown-up. Check their reviews, their curriculums, ask if they have an audio lab, what kind of outside activities they offer... And again, a deposit is fine, but pay most of the money once you've actually visited the place, met the teacher(s) and your host family (or visited the apartment etc...)
When you are going to pay is the key. If you have prepaid the whole thing, then you have almost no power to change anything you don't like.
5 - What I would do
To sum up, you need to be smart when picking a learning method. And you need to be honest about your learning abilities. If I was a student of French, this is what I would do:
- I would definitely start with some private lessons, to make sure the foundations are good.
- If I could afford it, I would then go to an immersion at the teacher's house, to learn a lot fast, and enjoy the culture.
- I would get some simple, level-adapted audio self-teaching tools for self-instruction to study on the side.
- I would join a good group (cheaper) or continue with private French lessons (faster and adapted to your own goals and needs).
