| By |

4b9f9da50cf2f358abdcd4a4321104f9
It sounds simple enough, but let me warn you: if it's easy to understand the rule, it's complicated to apply it. It's already hard enough for an English speaker to refer to a thing by him or her, yet it is even harder to use c'est + a person. It sounds in English like you are saying it's + person... very very bad... You need to train a lot on this concept before it becomes natural to you.
Download a great one page cheat sheet of this c’est ≠ il est lesson: PDF

“Il/elle est, or ils/elles sont” can indicate a location, the situation of something.
Où est le livre ? Il est sur la table.
Where is the book? It’s on the table.

It will be followed by a place, introduced by a preposition of place: sur, sous, dans, chez… and answer the question “where is/are…”.

This case is easy to translate.

The problem is when you want to say “he is a friend”, or “it’s fast”. When “to be” doesn’t indicate a location, you cannot just translate word by word from English. You need to apply a French logic to chose between a “c’est” or “il est” construction.

A – To Avoid Mistakes With C’est Versus Il est

In English, you say he is a friend, he is charming. So you use he is + noun (a friend) as well as he is + adjective (charming). Well, in French, we use 2 different constructions.

  • il/elle est + adjective qualificative (plural ils/elles sont)
    il est grand, elle est blonde, ils sont amusants.
    See my audio lesson on French adjectives to master their agreements and pronunciation.
  • c’est + (article, adjective possessive or demonstrative…) +  NOUN
    C’est un ami, c’est mon mari, c’est cette voiture, ce sont mes cousins (or c’est mes cousins… should be “ce sont +plural” – but we use c’est + plural a lot in spoken French although it’s a mistake…).

Adverbs (très, un peu, incroyablement…) don’t “count”. Dismiss them and look for the word that comes after: do you have a noun? If so, use “c’est”.

Examples (the nouns are in bold):

  • Le Père Noël: c’est un homme gentil. Il est très gros. Il est incroyablement généreux. C’est un personnage magique.
  • Les Jackson 5: Ils sont célèbres. Ce sont des chanteurs. Ils sont mignons et talentueux.

il est versus c'est

Tips About Il est Versus C’est

Look for the French articles (un, une, du, de la, de l’, des, le, la, l’, les)

If you have an article, it’s going to be followed by a noun.

  • So don’t say : “il est un / elle est une / il sont des etc…”.
    Say:  “c’est un, c’est une” with a strong liaison, “ce sont des” etc…. (But watch out for the adverb “un peu”: for that one you’d say “il est un peu timide” for example…

More About Il est Verus C’est

Now, the construction “il est un…” is not wrong. But it’s now used only in formal French, so much so that it now sounds “wrong” in spoken French. And it cannot be used in all situations.

In other words, it’s quite complicated, and forums go on and on about “c’est ≠ il est” because French people don’t seem to agree either :-) If you use my explanation, you won’t make any mistake. It might not be the big picture, but it’s practical.

 

Now, some particular cases…

B – Particular Cases Of Il est Versus C’est

1- French Adjectives that come before the noun

As you know, some French adjectives come before the noun; grand, petit, joli, jeune, vrai, bon, mauvais
So what should you do when you have a sentence with one of these adjectives?

Well, you have to see if the adjective is followed by a noun, or if it is alone. If there is a noun, use c’est.

  • C’est une belle voiture.
  • Elle est belle.

2 – Nouns of profession, nationality, religion

Nouns of profession, nationality, religion… can be used as adjectives – only if there is no other adjective describing it.

So, when it is used as an adjective, use il/elle est.

  • Il est français. Il est medecin. Elle est juive.

But you can also use it as a noun. In this case it needs a companion word (article, possessive or demonstrative adjectives….)

  • C’est un Français. C’est un medecin. C’est une juive.

Now, if you wanted to say “he is an intelligent Frenchman”, Frenchman cannot be an adjective because you have another adjective there.

You have only one possibility ;

  • C’est un Français intelligent. You cannot say Il est français intelligent

French noun gender masculine

3 – C’est + adjective masculine singular

To make a live comment, react to something, share your experience, we use the construction c’est + adjective masculine singular. It’s your emotion that comes through, not a specific description.

  • C’est beau ! c’est bon ! c’est chaud !

Watch out that the adjective cannot be in another gender/number ; c’est belle is not possible, even if you are looking at “la mer”(the sea). The construction demands a masculine singular adjective.

This construction is also use to make comments about something as a category:

  • la mer, c’est beau!
    I am not talking about one sea or ocean in particular, but all the seas in the world.

So, let’s imagine some scenarios:

You are talking about the Mediterranée : you could say.

  • Comme elle est belle, la mer Méditerranée. Elle est bleue, elle est transparente. C’est vraiment une belle mer.”

You are standing in front of the bay of Cassis, and are overwhelmed by the beauty of the landscape. You say

  • “Woah… c’est beau!!” – it’s your emotion speaking, you are talking about the sea but also the light, the rocks, the feeling you are having. Kind of “how gorgeous” in English.

So now, let’s have some examples.

4

Woah ! Comme c’est beau !

C – Examples Featuring C’est Versus Il est

First, let’s describe my friend Pierre using c’est and il est.

Voici mon ami Pierre. C’est un homme charmant (c’est + noun). Il est grand et brun (Il est + adj). Il n’est pas marié (il est + adj). C’est un bon musicien (c’est + noun). Il n’est pas riche, mais il est passionné (il est + adj). C’est un rêveur (c’est + noun), il est un peu timide (il est + adj), mais c’est un bon copain (c’est + noun).
This is my friend Peter. He is a charming man. He is tall and has brown hair. He is not married. He is a good musician. He is not rich, but he is passionate. He is a dreamer, he is a bit shy, but he is a good friend.

Now let’s imagine this dialogue between a Customer (C) and a Waiter (W), featuring il est versus c’est

C: Comment sont vos tartes ? How are your pies?
W: Ce sont des tartes faites maison (c’est + noun). Elles sont riches et copieuses (il est + adj). They’re home made pies. They are rich and copious.
C: Est-ce qu’elles sont chères (il est + adj) ? Are they expensive?
W: Non, elles ne sont pas chères (il est + adj). No, they’re not expensive.
C: Les tartes, c’est bon ! (c’est + category = adj masculine singular) Pies are tasty!
W: Oui, et nos tartes, elles sont vraiment délicieuses (il est + adj). Yes, and our pies, they are really delicious.

Now Let’s talk about “la mer” – the sea, which is feminine in French. Note where I say “c’est beau la mer”…

La mer est bleue. Elle est verte. Elle est violette. Elle est noire (il est + adj). C’est un élément changeant (c’est + noun). C’est toujours beau (c’est + category = adj masculine singular), la mer. Mais la mer des Iles grecques, elle est particulièrement belle (il est + adj).
The sea is blue. It is green. It is violet. It is black. It’s a changing element. The sea, it’s always beautiful. But the sea of the Greek islands, it’s particularly gorgeous.

Voilà, see it’s not that complicated after all :-) I suggest you bookmark this page to find it easily, and if you liked this article, you may click on the tag “grammar” located by the title to access more grammar articles, or follow the suggestions below.

My Final Tip

It’s of course useful to understand the grammatical logic behind the choice of “c’est versus il/elle est”, but ultimately, you need to develop a sense for it, “hear” what is right or wrong.

To achieve this, there is nothing like learning French in context.

I highly recommend you check out my unique downloadable French audiobooks, featuring different speeds of recording and enunciation, and focussing on today’s modern glided pronunciation, exclusively on sale on French Today.

I post new articles every week, so make sure you subscribe to the French Today newsletter – or follow me on Facebook, Twitter and Pinterest.


Liked This French Post? You Might Also Enjoy...

Si Hypothesis French Hypothesis in French - the Uses of Si + Audio
If the weather is nice tomorrow, I will go to the beach. The construction of hypothetical statements (if clauses) requires the use of specific tenses. Hypotheses...
Main Differences Between Passé Composé and Imparfait Passé Composé Versus Imparfait
In this lesson, I am not going to go over the constructions of Passé-Composé or Imparfait, but I will concentrate on their uses and differences.
spring2008 What do "La Bonne Éducation" et "la Bourgeoisie Française" Mean?
I first started to think about this subject when I realized my students were misunderstanding a very important French cultural point. When I said "elle a...
French Verb Drills Bundle - French Conjugation French Verb Drills - Bundle
Buy all 3 French Verb Drills and get my popular 3 hours 34 min masterclass: "French Verbs Fundamentals" for free (a $39.99 value)!

Camille Chevalier-Karfis

Born and raised in Paris, I have been teaching today's French to adults for 20 years in the US and France. Based on my students' goals and needs, I've created unique downloadable French audiobooks focussing on French like it's spoken today, for all levels. Most of my audiobooks are recorded at several speeds to help you conquer the modern French language. Good luck with your studies and remember, repetition is the key!

All blog posts from Camille Chevalier-Karfis...